I'm a fan (and you should be too) because...
Carrie Underwood is awesome. 
It's as simple as that. I don't know how else to put it. She is indeed, The American Idol, by all accounts. Her voice is unlike any Music Artist's that I've ever heard before. I can't help but turn up the radio when her songs start playing.
I can't put my finger on it, and I probably never will be able too, but It's just something about Carrie Underwood, that I just love. Maybe because She appears to be as normal as all of us? Then again, most country stars do. But Carrie does it best, if you ask me!
Can't wait to see you tonight! 11/19/08
Carrie - You did a wonderful job on the CMA's! Congratulations on your award! My husband and I are surprising our 5 year old daughter tonight and taking her to your concert in SLC. She is a huge fan!! She loves to stand on our coffee table with her pretend mic and sing along with your videos. We have pretty good seats on the floor, row 24. We can’t wait to see you and surprise our daughter. It will be a night she will never forget! Thanks for being such a good role model for little girls!!!